Llosa on self-censorship in the West

”Many people in the West misunderstand what freedom of expression means. They associate it with the restriction on the power of the government to interfere with the freedom to express oneself,” writes Alvaro Vargas Llosa.

An editor of ”Lessons from the Poor” and the director of the Center on Global Prosperity at the Independent Institute wrote in the International Hearld Tribune:

[Freedom of expression] is really a restriction on the power of anyone to interfere with anyone else’s right to free expression, including but not limited to the government. If a business decision is made under extreme fear - directly or indirectly caused by force from a third person rather than the government - freedom of expression also suffers.

Llosa writes about a decision taken by Random House, a book publisher, to cancel publication in the United States a novel “The Jewel of Medina,” written by American author Sherry Jones.

The novel fictionalizes the relationship between the Prophet Muhammad and his youngest bride, Aisha. After paying the author a significant advance and making plans for the release of the book, Random House sent copies of the galleys to various scholars, some of whom told the publisher that the content distorted history, would inflame Muslims and could cause much trouble. Security experts were also consulted. Random House decided to cancel publication of Jones’ work, invoking reasons of “safety.”

”Any time, any place in which the threat of violence inhibits the exercise of free expression, the imperfect freedoms of Western civilization that so many people around the world struggle to imitate are in danger…

The book’s content - which has been described, promisingly, as being full of sex and violence - is irrelevant to the discussion. It may well be, as one scholar who read it contends, that “The Jewel of Medina” is pure trash. And in any case, a book of historical fiction should never be judged on its accuracy. Great novels such as Tolstoy’s “War and Peace,” Victor Hugo’s “The Hunchback of Notre-Dame” and Marguerite Yourcenar’s “Memoirs of Hadrian” are all “inaccurate”…

The problem is not whether Random House was entitled to its decision, but what the decision to go against its own desire to publish the book tells us about the fear that fanaticism has instilled in Western countries through systematic acts of intolerance…

Featured stories on journalism, interactions and marketing of newspapers

Obama would win the US elections if they were held in eight other countries

Is not it a somewhat crazy idea? Canadian daily newspaper La Presse invited the leading titles from many countries of the world to make a poll about US presidential candidates. Seven newspapers followed. The result: Obama would win everywhere. An international... 

Stanislaw Lem’s unpublished works discovered

Newspaper’s idea to publish a collection of the greatest works by a science-fiction writer Stanislaw Lem helped to discover his unpublished opera on Stalin. Stanislaw Lem was 85 when he died in 2006. His books — like Solaris, Tales of Prix... 

Revealed: Pope John Paul Wounded by Priest in 1982

The Pope John Paul II was wounded by a knife-wielding priest in 1982, a year after he was shot in St Peter’s Square, but the injury was kept secret, his former top aide says in a documentary film, co-produced by a Polish newspaper. Cardinal Stanislaw... 

How to engage bloggers into the newspaper

Here are some tips from John Wilpers of Innovation: You need to go out into the community, find the quality bloggers, send them an e-mail or call them on the phone. ”It does not take a lot of convincing.” Mr. Wilpers, a consultant for Innovation Media... 

How to change our newspaper’s image

”When you try to change an image of a newspaper with a marketing campaign, changes in its content must follow. Otherwise there would be a disconnection between the new image and the content,” says Bernard Asselin, Vice President of The Gazette in... 

Mobile content: snack, speed & snip

”Content on mobile phone is all about snacking. All about speed. You just want little snippets of information,” says Annabel Hembry, Head of Communications at Associated Newspapers (UK). Ms. Hembry is responsible for mobile channels at the Mail titles... 

Media convergence: dare to make mistakes

“90 per cent of newspaper reporters can become good TV or radio journalists. It is not difficult. Don’t make it a rocket science,” says Ulrik Haagerup, Head of News at Danish Broadcasting Corporation and former newspaper editor. Mr....